Florida’s new generation of rappers have been courting controversy not just for their legal misdemeanours but also for their aesthetic unintelligibility. Their look is a pan-racial blend of face tattoos and multicoloured dreadlocks, their words are mumbled, emotions Auto-Tuned; repetition is key (see Lil Pump’s Gucci Gang).
Kodak Black is a key fixture of the scene. His reputation flourished when Drake posted his song Skrt, an off-kilter R&B-rap ballad, on Instagram and again when Cardi B referenced his track No Flockin on her 2017 hit Bodak Yellow. While he distinguished himself from his less coherent peers on diaristic tracks such as 2016’s Letter, in which he rapped from the perspective of a prison inmate, on Dying to Live the introspection falls flat.
While the melodies may be infectious, incorporating bright, upbeat steel drums on ZEZE and a floating synth on In the Flesh, both of which contrast pleasingly with Black’s drawl, it’s hard not to feel uncomfortable at the moralising of tracks such as Testimony and Malcolm X.X.X.
On the latter, Black eulogises XXXTentacion, the rapper who was accused of violently abusing his girlfriend before his murder this year. Black himself is awaiting trial for alleged rape but takes a preachy tone on Testimony, rapping that he is “God-sent … to relay these messages”. It’s a misfire: Black doesn’t have the novelty or innovation that has foisted this scene to prominence.